Referrally

The best roofers near Imlay City, Michigan, ranked by the record.

Scored out of 100 by our ranking algorithm from 174 Google reviews and state license records. Updated October 27, 2026.

See the 2026 awards
Text me this list
1
Ranked by an algorithm, not by ads.
2
Checked against the State of Michigan.
3
The most recommended roofers near Imlay City.
4
Every score shows its math.

6 roofers near Imlay City, ranked by Referrally Score · 17% license-verified

1

Elevation Roofing and Contracting

Attica · 4.1 mi from Imlay City

89OF 100
Excellent
Referrally Roofer of the Year 2026Most Recommended 2026Fastest Growing 2026
  • 4.9 · 76 Google reviews
  • Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • On Google since 2019
  • 14 new reviews in the last 12 months · replies to 93%
  • 1 review mention Almont

“Finished the job on schedule and the crew did a excellent job making sure the clean-up was done properly.” — Shannon Dinsdale

Friendly crew 41Would recommend 40On time / fast 302 critical
Call (810) 542-3918Website
See why Elevation Roofing and Contracting is #1
What customers say
Friendly crew 41Would recommend 40On time / fast 30Quality work 23Fair price 18No pressure 18Clean-up 15Communication 14

“Finished the job on schedule and the crew did a excellent job making sure the clean-up was done properly.”

Shannon Dinsdale, May 12, 2022
Anything to know
  • 2 critical reviews out of 76, mentioning no-show / delays, price / billing. The owner replied to 100% of them.
Recent activity

14 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 93% of reviews, usually within 257 days.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation32.4 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume12 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum8 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance8.9 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & recordpending

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness4.7 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity2.6 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns7 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
  • Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
  • Google listing: claimed by the owner
  • Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us
2

Bob Schmidt Roofing

Metamora · 7.6 mi from Imlay City

81OF 100
Very good
  • 4.8 · 26 Google reviews
  • Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • On Google since 2015
  • 6 new reviews in the last 12 months · replies to 54%

“He was respectful and helpful, answering all my questions patiently, and I will be calling when I replace my roof.” — Carey Shemes

Friendly crew 14Would recommend 11Quality work 91 critical
Call (248) 651-0212Website
See why Bob Schmidt Roofing is #2
What customers say
Friendly crew 14Would recommend 11Quality work 9On time / fast 7Clean-up 5Explained everything 4Storm / hail 4No pressure 3

“He was respectful and helpful, answering all my questions patiently, and I will be calling when I replace my roof.”

Carey Shemes, August 12, 2022
Anything to know
  • 1 critical review out of 26, mentioning leak after work, price / billing. The owner replied to 100% of them.
Recent activity

6 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 54% of reviews, usually within 44 days.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation30.8 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume9 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum5.7 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance9.4 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & recordpending

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness2.9 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity3.8 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns7 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
  • Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
  • Google listing: claimed by the owner
  • Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us
3

MichConn Property Services

Almont · 7.7 mi from Imlay City

80OF 100
Very good
  • 5.0 · 30 Google reviews
  • Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • On Google since 2022
  • 2 new reviews in the last 12 months · replies to 77%

“Brandon was very professional and kept us informed on the the progress of the work that was also completed on time.” — Judith Barbier

On time / fast 20Friendly crew 20Would recommend 14
Call (586) 864-6345Website
See why MichConn Property Services is #3
What customers say
On time / fast 20Friendly crew 20Would recommend 14Quality work 9Storm / hail 8Fair price 6Insurance help 5Communication 4

“Brandon was very professional and kept us informed on the the progress of the work that was also completed on time.”

Judith Barbier, September 12, 2023
Anything to know

No critical reviews (3 stars or lower) on record, and the reviews look typical for this area.

Recent activity

2 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 77% of reviews, usually within 201 days.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation33.6 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume9.4 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum3.2 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance9.4 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & recordpending

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness3.8 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity1.4 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns7 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
  • Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
  • Google listing: claimed by the owner
  • Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us
4

AZ Coatings

Almont · 5.9 mi from Imlay City

79OF 100
Very good
Most Responsive 2026
  • 5.0 · 25 Google reviews
  • Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • On Google since 2022
  • 3 new reviews in the last 12 months · replies to 96%

“I was very happy and very impressed with the quality, price and the time to complete the project.” — Jimmy Lumani

Quality work 12Friendly crew 10Would recommend 10
Call (248) 925-7414Website
See why AZ Coatings is #4
What customers say
Quality work 12Friendly crew 10Would recommend 10On time / fast 8Fair price 7Clean-up 2Communication 2No pressure 2

“I was very happy and very impressed with the quality, price and the time to complete the project.”

Jimmy Lumani, March 17, 2025
Anything to know
  • 9 of 25 reviews landed in one 7-day window.
Recent activity

3 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 96% of reviews, usually within 220 days.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation33.4 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume8.9 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum4.1 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance9.6 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & recordpending

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness4.8 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity1.4 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns5 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
  • Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
  • Google listing: claimed by the owner
  • Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us
5

E & J Construction of Mid-Michigan

Serves the area · 4.1 mi from Imlay City

70OF 100
Good
▼ 1 ptsince Oct 26
Longest Standing 2026

“The job was done in timely manner the workers were polite and they did a clean up better than I expected.” — Marvin Ford

Friendly crew 4On time / fast 1Clean-up 1
Call (810) 837-2804Website
See why E & J Construction of Mid-Michigan is #5
What customers say
Friendly crew 4On time / fast 1Clean-up 1Fair price 1Quality work 1Would recommend 1

“The job was done in timely manner the workers were polite and they did a clean up better than I expected.”

Marvin Ford, May 4, 2020
Anything to know

No critical reviews (3 stars or lower) on record, and the reviews look typical for this area.

Recent activity

0 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 20% of reviews, usually within 158 days.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation32.2 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume4.5 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum0 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance9.1 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & record6 of 6

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 9 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness1 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity4.2 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns7 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed -1 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us
6

Right Choice Improvements

Imlay City · 1.3 mi from Imlay City

61OF 100
Fair
▼ 1 pt, up 1since Oct 26
  • 4.4 · 12 Google reviews
  • Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • On Google since 2025
  • 6 new reviews in the last 12 months · replies to 0%

“Dominick and Rylan initially assessed our hail damaged roof and got the ball rolling with our insurance company.” — Chris Morisette

Insurance help 6Would recommend 5Communication 42 critical
Call (844) 857-3638Website
See why Right Choice Improvements is #6
What customers say
Insurance help 6Would recommend 5Communication 4Friendly crew 4Quality work 3Explained everything 3Storm / hail 3On time / fast 2

“Dominick and Rylan initially assessed our hail damaged roof and got the ball rolling with our insurance company.”

Chris Morisette, December 16, 2025
Anything to know
  • 2 critical reviews out of 12, mentioning poor communication. The owner replied to 0% of them.
  • 36% of reviews come from single-review accounts vs 16% typical for area roofers.
Recent activity

6 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 0% of reviews.

How the score adds up
  • Reputation27.6 of 35

    Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

  • Review volume6.9 of 12

    How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

  • Momentum5.7 of 8

    New reviews in the last 12 months.

  • Recent performance7.4 of 10

    Rating over the last two years.

  • Credentials & recordpending

    State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

  • Responsiveness0 of 8

    Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

  • Longevity0.5 of 5

    Years in business.

  • Review patterns4 of 7

    Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed -1 since 2026-10-26.

Verification
  • Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
  • Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
  • Google listing: claimed by the owner
  • Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.
Reviews read October 26, 2026 · license checked October 26, 2026Something wrong? Tell us

Too new to score (4): MCO Construction Co.,LLC · Schultz Roofing Corporation · Wells Family Construction · American Commercial Roofing, Inc. Fewer than 5 reviews each.

Named, not scored (2): All Star DUMPSTER RENTAL 248-634-(DUMP)ster-3867 Rubbish & Demo scrap metal machinery hauling (waste management service) · Kehrer Brothers Landscaping & Construction (landscaper). Google lists them under roofing as a side trade; their main trade is in brackets. We only score companies whose main category on Google is roofing; a company can change that on its Google profile.

About the roofers near Imlay City

6 roofers within 10 miles of Imlay City, Michigan made this list, led by Elevation Roofing and Contracting with a Referrally Score of 89, followed by Bob Schmidt Roofing and MichConn Property Services. Together they hold 174 Google reviews, and 1 of 6 has an active Michigan builder license on file. Imlay City is in Lapeer County; the circle also takes in Imlay Township, Attica, Attica Township, Goodland Township, Arcadia Township, Dryden.

Looking for roofing companies, roofing contractors or roof repair and roof replacement near Imlay City? They are all here. A company is listed as a roofer when Google lists that as its main trade; the same formula scores every one of them, and the full Michigan coverage is one click away.

What Imlay City homeowners say about local roofers

Across 174 reviews, the praise clusters around friendly crew, would recommend, on time / fast. Elevation Roofing and Contracting is recommended by name most often, in 40 reviews.

  • Friendly crew 93
  • Would recommend 81
  • On time / fast 68
  • Quality work 57
  • Fair price 32
  • Communication 24

Questions about roofers near Imlay City

Who is the top-rated roofer near Imlay City?

Elevation Roofing and Contracting ranks first with a Referrally Score of 89 out of 100, built from 76 Google reviews averaging 4.9 stars. Bob Schmidt Roofing and MichConn Property Services round out the top three. The score weighs seven public signals, and no company can pay to move up.

How many roofers near Imlay City are licensed?

1 of the 6 scored roofers match an active Michigan builder license by name or license number. Many companies hold their license under a different legal name; those show as pending rather than unlicensed until the match is confirmed.

How are roofers near Imlay City ranked?

Every company gets a score out of 100 from the same seven public signals: Google rating adjusted for review count, review volume, new reviews in the last year, the rating over the last two years, Michigan license and record, how the owner responds to reviews, years in business, and review patterns. The full method is on the How we rank page. How we rank.

Which towns does this list cover?

The list takes in every roofer based within 10 miles of Imlay City, which includes Imlay Township, Attica, Attica Township, Goodland Township, Arcadia Township, Dryden, Dryden Township, Almont, Almont Township, Capac. Companies based farther out are named below the list, not scored.

When was this list last updated?

This list was generated on October 27, 2026; reviews were read on October 26, 2026 and licenses checked on October 26, 2026. Every card shows its own dates.