The best roofers near Gibraltar, Michigan, ranked by the record.

“To my absolute surprise and delight, they had a team member out the very next day to complete the entire repair.”

• 5 critical reviews out of 139, mentioning rude / unprofessional. The owner replied to 20% of them.

50 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 73% of reviews, usually within 105 days.

• Reputation32.4 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume8 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum7.3 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9.8 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness3.5 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity2 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“The owner, Scott, is very professional and takes the time to fully explain the process from beginning to end!”

No critical reviews (3 stars or lower) on record, and the reviews look typical for this area.

26 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 95% of reviews, usually within 143 days.

• Reputation34.2 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume7.3 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum6.1 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9.9 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness4.8 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity0.6 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“I called about an inquiry, and spoke to Brianna who was very polite, informative and answered all my questions.”

• 36 critical reviews out of 1,615, mentioning price / billing, no-show / delays, damage / mess. The owner replied to 100% of them.

69 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 100% of reviews, usually within 519 days.

• Reputation28 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume12 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum7.8 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance6.9 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness5 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity0.7 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“Harley and his employees are very professional, reasonable in price and did a great job on my new roof.”

• 40% of reviews come from single-review accounts vs 14% typical for area roofers.

39 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 94% of reviews, usually within 10 days.

• Reputation33.8 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume6.3 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum6.8 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9.7 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & record6 of 6

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 9 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness5.7 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity0.4 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns2 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +1 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Licensed in Michigan · #262500629
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“They not only took care of my house but they were also friendly and professional answering all of my questions.”

• 1 critical review out of 36, mentioning no-show / delays, price / billing. The owner replied to 0% of them.

10 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 0% of reviews.

• Reputation32 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume5.8 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum4.4 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9.5 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness0 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity3.4 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“They have a crew that does their work and they’re in & out, excellent work, great clean-up, & they have very fair pricing.”

• 1 critical review out of 38, mentioning no-show / delays, price / billing. The owner replied to 0% of them.

2 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 29% of reviews, usually within 170 days.

• Reputation32.1 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume5.9 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum2 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9.5 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness1.4 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity3.4 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“I am 5 stars for 5 River Roofing as he knows his business well, experienced for years and quality of worked delivered was awesome.”

• 1 critical review out of 18, mentioning poor communication, price / billing. The owner replied to 0% of them.

0 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 89% of reviews, usually within 44 days.

• Reputation30.6 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume4.7 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum0 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance8.8 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness4 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity1.4 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“They did an excellent job.”

No critical reviews (3 stars or lower) on record, and the reviews look typical for this area.

0 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 0% of reviews.

• Reputation31.5 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume3.9 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum0 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance9 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & recordpending

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 15 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness0 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity3.4 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license not confirmed yet
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.

“The guys at Harleys went above and beyond working with my insurance to get it approved ....”

• 20 critical reviews out of 69, mentioning price / billing, no-show / delays, poor communication. The owner replied to 35% of them.

0 new reviews in the last 12 months. Replies to 22% of reviews, usually within 221 days.

• Reputation14.2 of 35

  Google rating, adjusted so a handful of reviews can't outrank hundreds.

• Review volume6.9 of 12

  How many reviews, compared with other companies nearby.

• Momentum0 of 8

  New reviews in the last 12 months.

• Recent performance1.5 of 10

  Rating over the last two years.

• Credentials & record0 of 6

  State license, discipline record, local presence, and BBB standing. 9 points still being verified.

• Responsiveness1.4 of 8

  Whether the owner replies to reviews, especially critical ones.

• Longevity3.5 of 5

  Years in business.

• Review patterns7 of 7

  Whether the reviews look like other companies' reviews in timing, wording, and who wrote them.

Score = points earned ÷ points we could verify, out of 100. Changed +0 since 2026-10-26.

• Michigan license: Michigan license status: Revoked
• Insurance certificate: not on file yet. Contractors add one by claiming their profile.
• Google listing: claimed by the owner
• Own this company? Get your Referrally badge or correct a record.